I have some questions... - Guild Wars Forums

[email protected] · May 04, 2007, 05:46 PM // 17:46

Hello, I just bought Guild Wars Phrophecies because I read some good reviews, and I am about to create my characters, but there are a few things I would like to know before I do, and I am sorry if these are noob questions, I checked the FAQ and didnt see them there so...

1- If Monk chooses Warrior as secondary, will that job be at least somewhat profiecient in melee attacks?

2-Will Primary Jobs (example monk) be able to equip the weapons or armours from another job (example warrior)that is their secondary?

3- Is there any form of martial arts, or some way to be strong in unarmed combat? If so which jobs?

4- Can any of the characters in this chapter get a whip as a weapon?

Thank you so much for you patience and I would REALLY appreciate the help.

P.S. If you havnt guessed yet I would really liek to have a character that wears light clothing and is profiecient in unarmed combat. And another character that uses a whip as a primary.... lol sounds kind of wierd.

[email protected] · May 04, 2007, 06:10 PM // 18:10

no... help for me...?

Coridan · May 04, 2007, 06:11 PM // 18:11

unfortunately there are not "hand to hand" or martial arts combat in GW. Although any character can use a weapon/item of any other "class" although they may not get max dmg from usiing it unless the meet the requirements for the item but they will get the "extra" bonus like hps or energy

a great place for you to check out is

www.guildwiki.org

it has a lot of information you should really take your time and look through it. I wouldn't suggest becoming a monk and then picking a warrior as a secondary just so you can mele fight...although in certain instances and in certain areas a monk can take much more damage than a warrior can but that is because of the skills you have... if you really want to be a warrior then pick a warrior...monks should mainly be about protection or healing...not in there dishing out a bunch of damage...although like i said before they can do great at it in certain places or with certain skills...but that is for a more advance player...do a search on 55 hp monk on the site i told you about.

I suggest making several characters and picking several different secondaries for each character before "choosing" which will be your first true character...lvl them up to lvl 5-7 and see which u like the best. Also just because you picked a secondary doesn't mean you can't switch it to another secondary later in the game...

Kook~NBK~ · May 04, 2007, 07:19 PM // 19:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by [email protected]

Hello, I just bought Guild Wars Phrophecies because I read some good reviews, and I am about to create my characters, but there are a few things I would like to know before I do, and I am sorry if these are noob questions, I checked the FAQ and didnt see them there so...

Welcome to GW! Hope you have a great time.

Quote:

1- If Monk chooses Warrior as secondary, will that job be at least somewhat profiecient in melee attacks?

There are Monks that are capable of soloing in the tough areas of the game, but for the regular portions, a Monk does not make a good melee class because of the low armor protection given.

Quote:

2-Will Primary Jobs (example monk) be able to equip the weapons or armours from another job (example warrior)that is their secondary?

Yes. Any profession can equip any weapon, no matter what. How useful that weapon will be depends on the player's skill and the skills they are using.

Quote:

3- Is there any form of martial arts, or some way to be strong in unarmed combat? If so which jobs?

The only Martial arts type profession is Assassin, which is a factions-only profession and they primarily use daggers and shakrams. If by "unarmed combat" you mean hand-to-hand melee, then no, there are no professions that work that way.

Quote:

4- Can any of the characters in this chapter get a whip as a weapon?

Nope, sorry

Thank you so much for you patience and I would REALLY appreciate the help.

P.S. If you havnt guessed yet I would really liek to have a character that wears light clothing and is profiecient in unarmed combat. And another character that uses a whip as a primary.... lol sounds kind of wierd.[/QUOTE]

malko050987 · May 05, 2007, 06:54 AM // 06:54

Indiana Jones xD A whip would be awesome.

Or those "ball tied to a stick with a chain" things. No idea how they're called, but having one to swing around would be awesome. Of course, I'd try it once and give it up, since I'm not a fan of melee

1. A Mo/W won't be as effective in melee because he's got weaker armor than a warrior, so he'll take more damage. While specific builds will make a solo monk almost unbeatable, in regular PvE monks are support units, keeping the damage dealers alive.

2. You can equip any weapon/shield/offhand from any profession. To get the full benefit of the equipment, you need to meet the requirement (req). By example, a Monk will be able to put 9 points in Divine Favor, and use a Staff that has a req 9 Divine Favor, and he will get the max damage from it. A Warrior, not having access to Divine Favor, will have minimum damage from that weapon. Of course, people would wonder what a big and strong warrior is doing with a staff

Waht do you understand by "light armor"? Appearance? Like, cloth, seemingly flimsy materials, etc, as opposed to the classic Warrior look, with metal armor?

Rangers have good armor as well, and some of the ranger armor sets can be called "light", such as Druid's.

However, in GW there isn't an armor classification based on Light and Heavy, like there is in Morrowind. Most people choose armor based on the benefits they give you, and after NF, based on looks.

erfweiss · May 05, 2007, 07:39 AM // 07:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by malko050987

Indiana Jones xD A whip would be awesome.

Or those "ball tied to a stick with a chain" things. No idea how they're called, but having one to swing around would be awesome. Of course, I'd try it once and give it up, since I'm not a fan of melee

It's known as a flail, for the record. Sometimes classified as a type of morning star.

malko050987 · May 05, 2007, 08:30 AM // 08:30

Ah, yes.

Thank you.

Toutatis · May 05, 2007, 08:46 AM // 08:46

Welcome to GW!

Quote:

1- If Monk chooses Warrior as secondary, will that job be at least somewhat profiecient in melee attacks?

I guess you could make a monk to be reasonable in the melee, if you invested points into one of the warrior's weapon mastery attributes. Although monks come with weaker armor, so you wouldn't have the same durability as a warrior.

Quote:

2-Will Primary Jobs (example monk) be able to equip the weapons or armours from another job (example warrior)that is their secondary?

Yes and no. You can equip any weapon/shield/focus you like, although to get the most out of items like those you will need to pay attention to the item's requirements (if you don't meet the requirements, you get less out of the item). When it comes to armor, you can only wear the armor of your primary profession. For example, a monk may only ever wear monk armor and a warrior can only ever wear warrior armor. It is not possible for a monk to wear warrior armor.

Quote:

3- Is there any form of martial arts, or some way to be strong in unarmed combat?

At the moment, it is not possible to attack without having a weapon equipped (although it is possible to use certain skills if you don't have a weapon equipped)

Quote:

4- Can any of the characters in this chapter get a whip as a weapon?

I wish! No whips in the game at the moment, to the best of my knowledge... But I'd love to see my Mesmer using one :P

*Darcy* · May 05, 2007, 11:31 AM // 11:31

Here's a little humor about a monk with a warrior secondary http://www.crithitcomics.com/botmanga01.htm

As stated by other posters, no un-armed combat in GW. All professions have a main attribute that is not available for use with a secondary. For a warrior this attribute is Strength, which increases the damage through armor penetration.

There is a Smiting Prayers attribute for monks. The skills in this line are focused on damage instead of healing.

May 04, 2007, 05:46 PM // 17:46	#1
[email protected] Pre-Searing Cadet Join Date: May 2007	I have some questions... Hello, I just bought Guild Wars Phrophecies because I read some good reviews, and I am about to create my characters, but there are a few things I would like to know before I do, and I am sorry if these are noob questions, I checked the FAQ and didnt see them there so... 1- If Monk chooses Warrior as secondary, will that job be at least somewhat profiecient in melee attacks? 2-Will Primary Jobs (example monk) be able to equip the weapons or armours from another job (example warrior)that is their secondary? 3- Is there any form of martial arts, or some way to be strong in unarmed combat? If so which jobs? 4- Can any of the characters in this chapter get a whip as a weapon? Thank you so much for you patience and I would REALLY appreciate the help. P.S. If you havnt guessed yet I would really liek to have a character that wears light clothing and is profiecient in unarmed combat. And another character that uses a whip as a primary.... lol sounds kind of wierd.

May 05, 2007, 11:31 AM // 11:31	#9
Darcy Never Too Old Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Rhode Island where there are no GW contests Guild: Order of First Profession: W/R	Here's a little humor about a monk with a warrior secondary http://www.crithitcomics.com/botmanga01.htm As stated by other posters, no un-armed combat in GW. All professions have a main attribute that is not available for use with a secondary. For a warrior this attribute is Strength, which increases the damage through armor penetration. There is a Smiting Prayers attribute for monks. The skills in this line are focused on damage instead of healing. __________________ That's me, the old stick-in-the-mud non-fun moderator. (and non-understanding, also)

May 04, 2007, 06:10 PM // 18:10	#2
[email protected] Pre-Searing Cadet Join Date: May 2007	no... help for me...?

May 04, 2007, 06:11 PM // 18:11	#3
Coridan Forge Runner Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: US Guild: Old Married Gamers {OMG} Profession: W/	unfortunately there are not "hand to hand" or martial arts combat in GW. Although any character can use a weapon/item of any other "class" although they may not get max dmg from usiing it unless the meet the requirements for the item but they will get the "extra" bonus like hps or energy a great place for you to check out is www.guildwiki.org it has a lot of information you should really take your time and look through it. I wouldn't suggest becoming a monk and then picking a warrior as a secondary just so you can mele fight...although in certain instances and in certain areas a monk can take much more damage than a warrior can but that is because of the skills you have... if you really want to be a warrior then pick a warrior...monks should mainly be about protection or healing...not in there dishing out a bunch of damage...although like i said before they can do great at it in certain places or with certain skills...but that is for a more advance player...do a search on 55 hp monk on the site i told you about. I suggest making several characters and picking several different secondaries for each character before "choosing" which will be your first true character...lvl them up to lvl 5-7 and see which u like the best. Also just because you picked a secondary doesn't mean you can't switch it to another secondary later in the game...

May 05, 2007, 06:54 AM // 06:54	#5
malko050987 Wilds Pathfinder Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Arad, Romania Guild: The Arctic Marauders [TAM] - now recruiting! Profession: R/	Indiana Jones xD A whip would be awesome. Or those "ball tied to a stick with a chain" things. No idea how they're called, but having one to swing around would be awesome. Of course, I'd try it once and give it up, since I'm not a fan of melee 1. A Mo/W won't be as effective in melee because he's got weaker armor than a warrior, so he'll take more damage. While specific builds will make a solo monk almost unbeatable, in regular PvE monks are support units, keeping the damage dealers alive. 2. You can equip any weapon/shield/offhand from any profession. To get the full benefit of the equipment, you need to meet the requirement (req). By example, a Monk will be able to put 9 points in Divine Favor, and use a Staff that has a req 9 Divine Favor, and he will get the max damage from it. A Warrior, not having access to Divine Favor, will have minimum damage from that weapon. Of course, people would wonder what a big and strong warrior is doing with a staff Waht do you understand by "light armor"? Appearance? Like, cloth, seemingly flimsy materials, etc, as opposed to the classic Warrior look, with metal armor? Rangers have good armor as well, and some of the ranger armor sets can be called "light", such as Druid's. However, in GW there isn't an armor classification based on Light and Heavy, like there is in Morrowind. Most people choose armor based on the benefits they give you, and after NF, based on looks.

May 05, 2007, 08:30 AM // 08:30	#7
malko050987 Wilds Pathfinder Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Arad, Romania Guild: The Arctic Marauders [TAM] - now recruiting! Profession: R/	Ah, yes. Thank you.